Heat Pump vs a New Air Conditioner in Monrovia
Choosing a Heat Pump or New Air Conditioner When Your Furnace Still Works
Call (626) 357-3535 to speak to our Air-Tro experts and talk through whether a heat pump or a straight air conditioner replacement fits your Monrovia home.
Your outdoor air conditioner has failed, but the furnace in the closet or attic still runs fine. That is a common situation in Monrovia and across the San Gabriel Valley. The decision is no longer just which cooling unit to install. You can replace the outdoor unit with another air conditioner, or you can choose a heat pump outdoor unit that cools in summer and can also heat in winter. Both options cool the house. The difference shows up on the colder evenings when the reversing valve in a heat pump lets the same outdoor equipment bring heat indoors.
In mild winters like the ones Monrovia, Pasadena, and the rest of the valley see, that extra capability is practical. Most nights stay above the range where a standard air-source heat pump struggles. The U.S. Department of Energy notes that a heat pump can deliver 1.5-3x more heat energy than the electrical energy it consumes under normal conditions, because it is moving heat rather than generating it. For homes that already have a working furnace, the heat pump becomes the primary heating and cooling source while the furnace remains available as a quiet backup on the rare colder nights.
Not sure which option fits your house? Call (626) 357-3535, and we will walk through the options with you.
What Changes When You Choose a Heat Pump Instead of a New Air Conditioner
A conventional air conditioner only cools. It moves heat from inside the house to the outdoors. A heat pump does the same thing in summer. In winter, the reversing valve flips the refrigerant flow, so the outdoor unit extracts heat from the outside air and brings it indoors. The indoor coil or air handler stays in place in most replacements, and the existing ductwork continues to distribute the air. The main difference is the outdoor unit and the controls that allow it to switch modes.
Cooling performance is essentially the same. Both systems are rated with SEER2 for cooling efficiency, and a high-efficiency heat pump cools as effectively as a high-efficiency air conditioner of the same capacity. The advantage appears when outdoor temperatures drop into the forties. On those evenings a heat pump can supply the heat most Monrovia homes need without the furnace running. If your furnace is still in good condition, it does not have to be removed. It simply waits for the nights that drop lower than usual.
Homes that do not have natural gas available see a clearer difference. Electric resistance heating costs significantly more to run than a heat pump. In fact, a heat pump with a coefficient of performance around 3 uses roughly 1/3 the electricity of resistance heat for the same amount of delivered warmth. In Monrovia and Pasadena, where gas is common but not universal, that efficiency still matters on the nights the heat pump handles the load alone.
Dual Equipment: Heat Pump as Your Primary, Furnace as a Backup
Many Monrovia and San Gabriel Valley homes end up with a dual-equipment arrangement even if that was not the original plan. The heat pump outdoor unit handles cooling and most of the heating. The existing gas furnace remains connected and only runs when outdoor temperatures fall low enough that the heat pump’s efficiency drops. In our climate, those hours are limited. The furnace is not removed, the gas line stays, and the thermostat is set, so the heat pump is the first choice.
This approach keeps the investment lower than a full system replacement while still giving you the efficiency of a heat pump for the majority of the year. It also leaves you with a reliable backup if a particularly cold stretch arrives or if the heat pump needs service. The decision is straightforward when the furnace is still in good shape and the outdoor unit is the part that has failed. Learn more about how mild local winters affect heat pump performance in our guide to heat pumps in Monrovia winters.
When a Full Heat Pump Replacement Makes More Sense
If both the outdoor air conditioner and the furnace are near the end of their useful life, replacing both with a single heat pump system is often the cleaner choice. You end up with one outdoor unit, one indoor air handler, and no combustion appliance to maintain. The same mild climate that makes dual options practical also makes a heat-pump-only system reliable for most homes. The furnace is removed, the gas line is capped, and the new equipment handles both seasons.
Your choice often depends on the age and condition of the furnace, the condition of the ductwork, and whether you want to keep gas available. And, a load calculation still matters. An older bungalow near Old Town Monrovia with original windows will have a different heating and cooling load than a newer foothill home with better insulation. Once the numbers are known, our equipment recommendation becomes clearer. For more on the factors that usually decide the selection, see what to consider before you install a heat pump in Monrovia.
Cooling Is the Same. It’s Winter That Shows the Difference
Homeowners sometimes worry that a heat pump will not cool as well as a dedicated air conditioner. In practice, the cooling side is nearly identical. Both use the same refrigeration cycle in summer. The heat pump simply adds the reversing valve and the controls that allow winter operation. Humidity removal in cooling mode is also comparable. The outdoor unit looks the same from the street, and the indoor comfort in July and August is the same.
The real distinction appears on winter evenings. A straight air conditioner does nothing for heat. A heat pump can supply it. In Monrovia, Pasadena, and the surrounding valley, that capability is useful without requiring a cold-climate model. Most of the heating hours stay within the efficient range of a standard air-source heat pump. If you want the full explanation of how the equipment switches between seasons, visit how heat pumps work in Monrovia and the San Gabriel Valley.
Installation, Permits, and Existing Equipment
Replacing an outdoor air conditioner with a heat pump is permitted mechanical work in Monrovia and across the San Gabriel Valley. The outdoor unit, the refrigerant lines, the electrical connection, and the controls all have to meet the current code. Our crews will help pull the permit, coordinate the inspection, and handle the refrigerant recovery and charging. If the indoor coil needs to be matched to the new outdoor unit, we’ll identify that well before the install day.
The existing furnace can stay in place in a dual-equipment setup. The thermostat is configured so that the heat pump is the primary source and the furnace is the backup. If the furnace is being removed, the gas line is properly capped and the new air handler is sized for both heating and cooling. Duct condition is checked either way. Older ducts that were sized for a furnace and air conditioner combination sometimes need minor adjustments when the system changes, but many homes require none.
Rebates and incentives change from year to year. Some programs cover heat pump installations more generously than straight air conditioner replacements. The practical step is to ask what is actually available for your address at the time you are ready. Current options are listed, so you can see which heat pump rebates are open right now without relying on expired numbers.
Where We Install and Service Heat Pumps and Air Conditioners
Service trucks leave from our headquarters at 1630 S. Myrtle Ave. in Monrovia. Most of the homes we work on aren’t far from there and are in Monrovia itself, Pasadena, Arcadia, San Marino, Sierra Madre, Duarte, Bradbury, Altadena, Temple City, San Gabriel, South Pasadena, Glendora, and La Cañada Flintridge. We serve all of the San Gabriel Valley, and our team regularly serves the surrounding communities.
Whether you are deciding between a heat pump and a new air conditioner, need the existing outdoor unit repaired, or want a second opinion on the furnace that is still running, the our local team handles the work. Learn more about full heat pump installation and service in Monrovia or about heat pump repair when the unit stops heating or cooling.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Replace My Air Conditioner With a Heat Pump and Keep My Furnace?
Yes. Many Monrovia and Pasadena homes do exactly that. The outdoor unit becomes a heat pump, the furnace stays in place, and the thermostat is set so that the heat pump handles most of the heating, while the furnace is available for the coldest nights.
Does a Heat Pump Cool as Well as a New Air Conditioner?
Yes. In cooling mode, a heat pump uses the same refrigeration cycle as an air conditioner. Capacity and efficiency ratings are comparable. The difference is the ability to reverse and provide heat in winter.
Is Dual Equipment a Good Choice in Monrovia?
For most homes with a working furnace, yes. The mild winters mean the heat pump handles the majority of heating hours efficiently, and the furnace remains as a reliable backup without being removed.
Do You Pull Permits for Heat Pump or Air Conditioner Replacements in Monrovia?
Yes. Both are permitted mechanical work. We handle the permit, the inspection, and the refrigerant work, so the installation is complete and code-compliant.
What If My Furnace Is Also Old?
If the furnace is near the end of its life, a full heat pump system that handles both heating and cooling is often the simpler long-term choice. We look at the age and condition of both pieces of equipment before recommending anything.
Click Here for More Detailed Heat Pump FAQs
Let Us Help You Choose Between a Heat Pump vs a New Air Conditioner When You Already Have a Furnace
The choice comes down to whether you want the outdoor unit to handle winter heat as well as summer cooling. In Monrovia, Pasadena, and the San Gabriel Valley, the mild climate makes a heat pump practical, especially when a working furnace can stay as backup. If you want to talk through your current equipment, your house, and which option fits, call (626) 357-3535. We can look at what you already have and schedule a time to walk through the options.

